The Mermaid & The Alligator

✓ We compared prices across top booking sites · ✓ No hidden fees · ✓ Secure booking
📱 Digital nomad friendly 🎒 Budget friendly
9.0 Exceptional · 6 reviews 729 Truman Avenue
👍 Guest Favourite (9.0/10) 👥 6 Reviews
🛏 See all available rooms & live prices
Real-time availability and room types on the booking platform
Check Availability →

About The Mermaid & The Alligator

Key West (FL)'s best experiences cost nothing — the city center and main attractions, wandering through museums and galleries , soaking up the atmosphere. The Mermaid & The Alligator understands this, offering stylish rooms at prices that let you actually enjoy the city.

It's not just us — 6 travelers have rated The Mermaid & The Alligator 9.0/10 (Exceptional). What keeps adventure seekers coming back is the excellent location for the price.

Practical touches matter: The Mermaid & The Alligator provides Free WiFi, Common Area, Air Conditioning, plus 5 additional amenities. Everything is designed with adventure seekers in mind.

Whether you're in Key West (FL) for local restaurants and street food or simply passing through, The Mermaid & The Alligator offers strong value. Compare prices from 50+ booking sites on JustCheckin.in to lock in the best rate.

📅 Check-in: 03:00 PM
📅 Check-out: 11:00 AM
🏨 Type: Hotel

Amenities & Features

📶 Free WiFi Free high-speed internet in all rooms and common areas
Common Area
❄️ Air Conditioning Individual room temperature control
Hot Shower
Fan
Shared Kitchen
Reading Light
Self Check-in
💬

Community Verdict

Could not load community reports.
✈️

Be the first to report on this city!

reports so far — share yours!

Rate this destination

Guest Reviews

9.0
Exceptional
Based on 6 guest reviews on Agoda
Staff 9.3
Value 8.2
Comfort 9.1
Location 9.0
Facilities 8.9
Cleanliness 9.4
  • One of our most booked properties in this city.
  • Breakfast was highlighted as exceptional by recent guests.
  • Popular with families — kids activities and family rooms available.

Rated 9.0/10 (Exceptional) by 6 guests. Read reviews on Agoda →

Sign in to write a review

Location

📍 729 Truman Avenue

What's Nearby

Looking up nearby places…

Data from OpenStreetMap

Compare Prices
Prices last checked 1 month ago
Agoda Check price Book → Booking.com Check price Book →
🚐
Need an airport transfer? Pre-book for stress-free travel — private, shared & shuttle options
Compare Transfers
Own or manage this property?
Claim it for free to update photos, add booking links, and get a verified badge.
Claim This Hotel

More Hotels in Key West (FL)

24 North Hotel Key West 4★ Upscale -10%

24 North Hotel Key West

Key West (FL) · ★★★★

7.8 Very Good · 334 reviews
$188 from $169 /USD
Compare & Book →
✓ Best price across 3 sites
Havana Cabana at Key West 4★ Upscale

Havana Cabana at Key West

Key West (FL) · ★★★★

8.2 Excellent · 330 reviews
from $132 /USD
Compare & Book →
✓ Best price across 6 sites
THE GATES HOTEL KEY WEST 4★ Upscale

THE GATES HOTEL KEY WEST

Key West (FL) · ★★★★

7.7 Very Good · 204 reviews
from $132 /USD
Compare & Book →
✓ Best price across 5 sites
NYAH - Adult Exclusive

NYAH - Adult Exclusive

Key West (FL) · ★★★

7.5 Very Good · 197 reviews
from $203 /USD
Compare & Book →
✓ Best price across 3 sites
Oceans Edge Key West 4★ Upscale

Oceans Edge Key West

Key West (FL) · ★★★★

8.1 Excellent · 182 reviews
from $198 /USD
Compare & Book →
✓ Best price across 5 sites
Ibis Bay Resort

Ibis Bay Resort

Key West (FL) · ★★★

7.5 Very Good · 175 reviews
Check Availability
Compare & Book →
Check Price 9.0 · 6 reviews
Check Price
✨ Jiai — Travel AI Open Full →
Hi! I'm **Jiai**. Ask me about hotels, flights, activities or budgets for any destination.
✈️

You're on a roll!

Enter your email for unlimited Jiai access + personalised travel deals.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.