Amara Cay Resort ★★★★

Name: Amara Cay Resort
Address: Islamorada (FL), US
Rating: 8.4

✓ We compared prices across top booking sites · ✓ No hidden fees · ✓ Secure booking

8.4 Excellent · 121 reviews 80001 Overseas Highway

From

$185

per USD

Reserve Now

⭐ 4-Star Property 👍 Guest Favourite (8.4/10) 👥 121 Reviews

🔍

Regret Risk

Analysing 121 reviews — results available soon.

📊

Price Oracle

Price trend analysis being computed — check back soon.

🛏 See all available rooms & live prices

Real-time availability and room types on the booking platform

Check Availability →

About Amara Cay Resort

What sets Amara Cay Resort apart in Islamorada (FL)'s hotel market is its commitment to understated quality. This 4-star property won't overwhelm you with excess — instead, expect spacious rooms, comfortable beds, and staff who remember your name.

Across 121 guest reviews on Agoda, Amara Cay Resort maintains a 8.4/10 score (Excellent).

Islamorada (FL) rewards those who explore beyond the obvious — and Amara Cay Resort makes the perfect base for doing exactly that. Compare prices from $185/night across Agoda, Booking.com, and other top platforms on JustCheckin.in.

📅 Check-in: 04:00 PM

📅 Check-out: 11:00 AM

🏠 Rooms: 110

🏨 Type: Hotel

Guest Reviews

8.4

Excellent

Based on 121 guest reviews on Agoda

Rated 8.4/10 (Excellent) by 121 guests. Read reviews on Agoda →

Location

📍 80001 Overseas Highway

What's Nearby

Looking up nearby places…

Data from OpenStreetMap

Compare Prices

Prices last checked 4 months ago

Agoda $185/night Book → Booking.com Check price Book →

Book This Hotel

Check-in

Check-out

Guests

2 adults

ⓘ Check cancellation policy on partner site

From

$185 / USD

Check on Agoda →

Prices last updated 4 months ago. Final price on booking site.

Share with a friend and get an exclusive booking link

📱 Share on WhatsApp

🛡️

Travel Smart

Don't Travel Without Insurance

Medical emergencies abroad can cost $50,000+. SafetyWing covers you from just $56/month — pay as you go, cancel anytime.

Get Covered from $56/mo →

SafetyWing · Used by 100,000+ travellers

Compare Prices

Agoda Best Price

$185/night

Booking.com

Check

Hotels.com

Check

Expedia

Check

🔔 Sign in to set price alert

Own a property? List it free →

Quick Facts

Check-in 04:00 PM

Check-out 11:00 AM

Property class 4-Star Luxury

Guest rating 8.4 / 10

Rooms 110

🚐

Need an airport transfer? Pre-book for stress-free travel — private, shared & shuttle options

Compare Transfers

Own or manage this property?

Claim it for free to update photos, add booking links, and get a verified badge.

Claim This Hotel

Frequently Asked Questions about Amara Cay Resort

How much does a night at Amara Cay Resort cost?

Rates at Amara Cay Resort start from around $185 per night, based on recent pricing. Actual rates vary by date and availability — compare live prices above.

Is Amara Cay Resort a good place to stay?

Amara Cay Resort has a guest rating of 8.4/10 from 121 verified reviews.

What time is check-in and check-out at Amara Cay Resort?

Check-in is from 04:00 PM and check-out is until 11:00 AM.

Is Amara Cay Resort suitable for families?

Amara Cay Resort is marked as family-friendly, making it a solid option for travellers with children.